Boy, were WE confused!  Turns out this is a book based on a t.v. series, written by a guy who doesn’t really exist, about characters that are based on characters from the t.v. show.  Or something.

Joan’s head hurt just trying to figure this out.

Some in the group knew what was going on and loved it, others hadn’t a clue and still loved it.  So there you go.

On the whole, we enjoyed this.  It had aspects of Nick and Nora Charles/Thin Man mysteries which we enjoyed.  Witty repartee, hot characters, all around fun.

But if a reader hadn’t seen the show, they felt like there wasn’t enough depth or background, and, ironically, the story felt scripted.  We found it predictable, and yet unpredictable and it was generally agreed that if you’d seen the show, it was hard to read.

The book didn’t just re-create one episode of the show.  It would seem that this story stretched out over a number of episodes.

We thought Nikki Heat was an interesting character and it was an interesting, albeit convoluted, story.  The boyfriend was charming in a rogue-ish way though Joan kept waiting for him to do something asinine and then they’d break up.  The relationship is a little too perfect and cutesy.

Which brings us to the story.  It’s ALL a little too perfect.  Stereotypes abound, from the top of the PD pile all the way down to the hooker on the street.  There were a number of incongruities and it felt like the writer(s) were trying to trick the reader.

But will all that, we enjoyed the book.

Favorite – Jameson Rook, the boyfriend.  I mean how can you NOT be charmed?  People liked his jokes and puns.  Nikki, as well as the two as a couple.  Team Roach.

Least Favorite – Sharon, the Hammer, Phyllis, the crooked cops, Nikki (professionally great, in her private life she was all messed up).  Montrose.  Those of us who hadn’t seen the show had never seen him when he wasn’t acting the ass.


Don’t forget — our book in June has been changed to Midnight in Peking by Paul French